The Complete Guide to Replacing Your Roof: Costs, Materials, Timing and Insurance

A new roof is one of the most expensive repairs a house ever needs, and it is also one of the easiest to get wrong, because it happens rarely, quotes are hard to compare and the decision is usually made in a hurry after a leak or a storm. This guide takes you through the whole process in the order you will meet it: whether to repair or replace, what it costs, which material fits your climate, how to compare bids, how insurance works and what to do if you want solar on the same roof.

$5,000 to $20,000typical asphalt shingle replacement, according to HomeGuide
$3 to $6installed cost per square foot of asphalt shingles, before tear-off
$3,000repair quote above which our repair guide suggests thinking hard about replacing
25 and 50 yearsmidpoints we use for asphalt and metal when comparing cost per year of life

Prices come from published sources, mainly HomeGuide, HomeAdvisor and Angi, and where they disagree we show both. Roof prices vary by region, material, pitch and the contractor’s workload, so treat every range as a place to start a conversation, not as a quote.

Repair or replace: the first decision

Most people call a roofer because of a leak and assume the answer is a new roof. Often it is not. Repairs are far cheaper, but they only make sense when the rest of the roof still has years in it. Our repair or replace guide uses HomeGuide’s price list to show the range: a repair of part of the roof runs from about $1,000 to $5,000, and a leak with water damage underneath can run from $1,000 to $6,000 or more. Add the minimum service visit, usually $150 to $300, and an inspection, which costs $100 to $400. Emergency work adds $200 to $300. Labor is 60% or more of a repair, which is why small jobs cost more per square foot than a full replacement.

Repair is usually right when

The roof is young, the damage is limited to a small area and the quote is well under $3,000. Think of a ten-year-old asphalt roof with damage on about 10% of the surface and a $900 quote.

Replace is usually right when

Damage covers more than about a quarter of the roof, the roof is near the end of its life or repairs keep coming back. A twenty-year-old roof with a $3,400 quote for the same kind of damage is a different case.

If you are going to sell soon, work out how much life the roof has left. Angi suggests replacing when less than five to eight years remain, because a buyer’s inspector will find the age. Before you approve any repair, ask the roofer to show you the damage with photos, to explain whether the cause is local or the roof is failing in general, and to write down what the repair does and does not cover.

What a new roof costs

Roofing prices are quoted in three ways, and mixing them is the most common source of confusion: per square foot, per “square” (100 square feet of roof) and as a total for the house. A quote of $450 per square is $4.50 per square foot. Our article on the cost per square foot lists the HomeGuide ranges by material. For asphalt shingles the installed price is about $3 to $6 per square foot, and the sources do not agree among themselves: one HomeGuide page gives $300 to $600 per square and another $400 to $900.

Cost by house size

House size is not roof size: the roof is larger than the floor area because of its pitch and overhangs. A 2,500 square foot house has a roof of about 2,795 square feet, and a 3,000 square foot house about 3,355 square feet.

House sizeRoof areaAsphalt shingle price (HomeGuide)
2,500 sq ft2,795 sq ft$8,500 to $16,800
3,000 sq ft3,355 sq ft$10,100 to $20,100

Source: HomeGuide table in our roof cost by house size article. HomeAdvisor and Angi give higher figures, from about $7,000 to $37,000, because their tables assume “common materials” at $4 to $11 per square foot, which includes costlier materials than asphalt.

You can estimate your own roof with our roof replacement calculator by state, which multiplies your roof area by the price per square foot for each material and adds the regional adjustment.

What is not in the price per square foot

  • Tear-off of the old roof: $1 to $5 per square foot, sometimes quoted separately.
  • Decking repairs: $2 to $5 per square foot where the boards underneath are rotten.
  • Hauling and disposal: $500 to $1,500 according to HomeAdvisor.
  • Steep pitch: $1,000 to $3,000 extra, because the crew needs extra safety equipment and works more slowly.
  • Permits, which vary by town.

A bid that does not itemize these may leave them out of the price and add them later. Complexity costs more than size: a small roof with many valleys, dormers and chimneys can cost more than a large simple one.

Choosing the material

The best material depends on your climate, your budget and how long you plan to stay. The sources we use recommend different materials for different risks, and no single material is the best in all of them. Our guide to the best roofing materials by climate covers each case in detail. In short, metal is recommended by the sources in most conditions, asphalt shingles are the most economical and widely used, tile does well in heat and fire but not in earthquakes, and slate lasts longest but is heavy and expensive.

Light-colored and reflective roofs help in hot climates. They can lower the surface temperature by 50°F or more and cooling energy by up to 15%, and white materials reflect 60% to 90% of sunlight, according to AmeriPro. In cold climates the priority is different: snow load, ice dams and ventilation matter more than reflectivity.

Metal or asphalt: cost per year, not cost per roof

Metal costs much more upfront, but it lasts roughly twice as long. If you take the midpoint of the lifespan ranges, 25 years for asphalt and 50 for metal, and divide a mid-range price by it, you get about $420 a year for asphalt against $440 a year for metal. In other words, the difference is small once you count the whole life of the roof, which is why our metal vs. asphalt comparison works with cost per year of life, not the upfront price. If you plan to stay for decades, the longer-lived option tends to come out ahead; if you may sell in a few years, the upfront cost counts for more.

How long each roof lasts

Lifespan figures vary by source, so be wary of any single number. Slate can last up to 100 years, with a range of 50 to 150, and clay or concrete tile 50 to 100 years or more, according to Angi and Home Depot. Climate, ventilation, installation quality and maintenance all move the figure up or down. Our article on how long a roof lasts compares five sources and shows how to estimate the years left on your own roof. A warranty is not the same as lifespan: a 30-year shingle warranty does not mean the shingles will last 30 years in your climate.

How to compare roofing quotes

Collect at least three written bids, and make sure each describes the same job. Our guide to comparing roofing quotes includes a grid you can fill in for each bid. A good quote names the material and its brand and line, states whether the old roof is torn off or covered, lists the decking and flashing work, says who handles the permit and cleanup, and gives a start date and a completion estimate.

Ask every contractor

Are you licensed and insured in this state? Who will be on the roof? How many roofs like mine did you do last year? Can I see the permit before work starts?

Red flags

A price that is much lower than the others, a demand for a large deposit up front, pressure to sign on the spot, no written contract and a refusal to show proof of insurance.

Two warranties, not one

The manufacturer warrants the material. The contractor warrants the workmanship. The second matters more if a leak appears at a flashing, so ask how long it lasts and who honors it.

Pay according to a schedule tied to the work, not to a date. Keep the final payment until the job is finished and you have inspected it, and keep copies of the contract, the permit, the warranties and the photos of the work.

Paying with insurance

Insurance may pay for a roof when the damage comes from a covered event such as hail, wind or a fallen tree, but not for wear and age. How much you receive depends on whether your policy pays actual cash value or replacement cost. Our article on replacing a roof with insurance follows the NAIC’s examples.

Policy type$15,000 storm loss, $1,000 deductible
Replacement costYou receive $14,000
Actual cash value, with $6,000 of depreciation (illustrative figure)You receive $8,000 and cover the rest

The first line is the NAIC’s example. The $6,000 depreciation is our own illustrative number, not an NAIC figure.

Read the roof section of your policy before a storm: some insurers apply a separate wind or hail deductible, others limit coverage for old roofs. After damage, document everything with dated photos, ask the insurer for the claim number and the adjuster’s report in writing, and do not sign a contract that lets a contractor negotiate the claim in your name before you understand it. Be wary of door-to-door contractors after a storm who offer to “waive the deductible”; in many states that is illegal, and it can put your claim at risk. If you disagree with the decision, you can request a reinspection, send your own estimates and ask your state’s insurance department how to file a complaint.

Roof and solar: how to time them

If you want solar panels in the next several years and your roof is already middle-aged, replace the roof first or at the same time. Taking panels off and putting them back later adds labor, and a roof that fails under panels is expensive to fix. Our guide to solar shingles vs. solar panels compares the two approaches. Panels cost about $2.50 to $3.50 per watt according to This Old House, with efficiencies of 17% to 20%, against shingles at up to about $9 per watt with 14% to 18%. For a 6 kW system that is roughly $15,000 to $21,000 for panels and up to $54,000 for shingles (our own multiplication), which is why panels on a normal roof are usually the better value.

For the full picture of what solar costs and saves, see our complete guide to going solar.

A practical order of operations

  1. Get an inspection and photos of the problem, from a roofer who is not selling you the replacement.
  2. Decide repair or replace using the age of the roof, the share that is damaged and the quote.
  3. Check your insurance before any work if the damage came from a storm.
  4. Choose the material for your climate and for how long you will stay.
  5. Collect three written bids that describe the same job and compare them in a grid.
  6. Confirm the license, insurance, permit and warranties before you sign.
  7. Inspect the finished work and keep your documents.

The best time of year to schedule is usually in the shoulder seasons, when roofers are less busy and the weather is mild; if the roof is leaking, though, do not wait for the ideal month. A temporary cover is cheap compared with water damage inside the house.

The parts of a roof you do not see in the quote

A shingle roof is a system, and the shingles are only the top layer. Underneath them are the parts that decide whether the roof keeps water out for twenty years or leaks in five, and these are the lines a cheap bid tends to skip or describe vaguely.

  • Decking. The boards or sheets under the roof covering. Soft, stained or rotten areas have to be replaced, and the price per square foot for that work is separate from the roof itself.
  • Underlayment. A water-resistant layer between the decking and the shingles. In cold climates an extra self-adhering membrane along the eaves helps against ice dams.
  • Flashing. The metal that seals the joints around chimneys, vents, skylights and walls. Most leaks start here, not in the middle of a shingle field, so ask whether the flashing will be replaced or reused.
  • Drip edge. A metal strip along the edges that guides water into the gutter and away from the fascia and decking.
  • Ventilation. Air moving through the attic keeps the decking dry in winter and cooler in summer. Poor ventilation shortens the life of the shingles and can void a manufacturer warranty.

When two bids differ by a few thousand dollars, compare these items first. The cheaper bid is often not cheaper at all; it simply does not include the work the other one does.

Signs that your roof needs attention

You do not need to climb up to learn a lot about your roof. A pair of binoculars from the ground and a look at the attic on a bright day are enough to start. Our lifespan guide lists the signs in detail; these are the ones that matter most.

  • Shingles that are curled, cracked or missing, or bare patches where the granules have worn away.
  • Granules in the gutters, which means the surface of the shingles is wearing out.
  • Dark streaks or moss. Streaks are often only cosmetic, but moss holds moisture against the roof.
  • Sagging areas, which can mean decking or framing problems and should be looked at quickly.
  • Daylight in the attic, stains on the ceiling or the rafters, or a musty smell after rain.
  • A sudden rise in the cooling bill, which can point to a roof that is no longer reflecting or ventilating as it should.

Never walk on a roof you suspect is damaged, and do not go up on a wet or steep one. A leak is also a reason to act quickly: water damage to insulation and ceilings costs far more to fix than the roof repair that would have stopped it.

Climate notes: heat, cold, wind and hail

Where you live changes the roof you should buy and the way it should be installed. A few rules of thumb help you ask the right questions, while our guide to materials by climate gives the full comparison.

Hot and sunny

Choose light or reflective surfaces and good attic ventilation. A cooler roof reduces the load on the air conditioner, and it may be one of the cheapest ways to cut a summer bill.

Cold and snowy

Pay attention to insulation and ventilation so that heat from the house does not melt snow unevenly and form ice dams. Metal and slate shed snow well, but they need snow guards where people walk below.

Windy or hail-prone

Ask for the wind and impact ratings of the product, not only its name. Fastening method, starter strips and sealing matter as much as the material, and insurers sometimes discount for impact-rated roofs.

If your area has more than one risk, as many do, choose for the one that causes the most damage in your region, and use the installation details to cover the rest.

How a roof affects your energy bill

The roof sits between the sun and your attic, so it influences what you pay for cooling and heating. A light, reflective roof lowers the heat that reaches the attic, and the attic’s insulation and ventilation decide how much of that heat enters the living space. If you are replacing the roof, it is the best time to check the attic: adding insulation costs less when the work is already underway and the house is open. Our attic insulation calculator shows what that investment saves, and how much insulation you need tells you the level to aim for in your climate zone.

A new roof will not change your bill dramatically on its own, so do not let a salesperson promise large savings from the roof alone. It is better to treat the roof as protection for the house and use the project to improve the parts around it, such as ventilation and insulation, which do affect the energy you use.

Keeping the new roof in good shape

Most roofs do not fail because of one big event; they fail because small problems were ignored. A short routine extends the life of the roof and may be needed to keep the warranty valid.

  1. Look at it twice a year, in spring and in autumn, and after any big storm.
  2. Keep the gutters clean so water does not back up under the edge of the roof.
  3. Trim branches that touch the roof, because they scrape the surface and drop leaves that hold moisture.
  4. Fix small things early: a loose flashing or a few missing shingles cost little compared with a leak.
  5. Keep every document: the contract, the permit, the manufacturer’s registration and the photos taken at the end of the work.

These habits cost almost nothing, and they are what turns a 25-year estimate into 25 years in practice.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a new roof cost?

For asphalt shingles, HomeGuide puts a typical replacement at about $5,000 to $20,000, depending on the size of the roof, with a price of $3 to $6 per square foot. Other sources give higher ranges because they include more expensive materials.

How long does a roof replacement take?

A typical house takes a few days of work once the materials arrive, but weather, a complicated roof and decking repairs can add time. Ask for a start date and an estimate in writing.

Can I put a new roof over the old one?

Sometimes, but it hides problems in the decking and adds weight, and many contractors recommend tearing off. Ask for both options in writing, with the price of tear-off at $1 to $5 per square foot.

Does insurance pay for a new roof?

It can when the damage comes from a covered event, but not for age. Whether you receive replacement cost or actual cash value depends on your policy.

Is a metal roof worth the extra cost?

If you stay for decades, often yes, because it lasts about twice as long as asphalt. Per year of life the difference is small. See our comparison.

Should I replace the roof before installing solar?

If the roof is more than halfway through its life, replacing it first or at the same time usually costs less than removing and reinstalling panels later.

If you are at the start of this decision, begin with the repair or replace guide, then use the roof calculator by state to set a budget and the quote comparison guide when the bids arrive. For materials, read best materials by climate, and if insurance is involved, how claims work. The figures in this guide come from HomeGuide, HomeAdvisor, Angi, the NAIC and the other sources named in each article. They are estimates for general information, not a quote or professional advice. Read how we research and update our guides.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top