Replacing a Roof With Insurance: How Claims Work

CLAIM

Insurance may pay for a new roof if the damage was caused by a storm, wind or hail, but not if it is wear and tear. How much you collect depends mostly on whether your policy pays replacement cost or only actual cash value, on the deductible and on the age of the roof.

How much would insurance pay for your roof?

Deductible you pay–
Estimated depreciation–
Payout with an actual cash value policy–
Payout with a replacement cost policy–
Difference between the two–

Our own calculation. The NAIC explains that insurers calculate depreciation based on condition, new cost and the material’s lifespan, but gives no formula: here we estimate it in a straight line (age divided by lifespan), and your insurer may use another. The $15,000 and the $1,000 deductible are the NAIC’s example; the age and lifespan are our own assumptions. If your deductible is a percentage, enter the percentage and your home’s coverage.

Actual cash value or replacement cost

It is the difference that moves the most money. With a replacement cost policy, insurance pays for the repair or replacement without subtracting depreciation. With an actual cash value one, it subtracts what the roof had already lost to age and condition. It is the distinction the NAIC explains with this example.

$15,000 of roof damage and a $1,000 deductible (NAIC example)Replacement cost policy$14,000$1,000Actual cash value policy$4,000$10,000$1,000What insurance paysDepreciation (on you)Deductible
NAIC example (2021): two families with $15,000 of damage and a $1,000 deductible.
Policy typeWhat it paysNAIC example
Replacement costRepairs or replaces the roof without subtracting depreciation$15,000 of damage minus a $1,000 deductible: pays $14,000
Actual cash valueSubtracts depreciation based on the roof’s condition and ageThe same damage with $10,000 of depreciation: pays $4,000

Source: NAIC, rebuilding after a storm: replacement cost vs. actual cash value (July 22, 2021).

What it covers and what it does not

Covers

Storm, wind or hail damage

A homeowners policy may cover wind and hail damage, although the NAIC warns that some exclude it, which is common in coastal areas, and that they sometimes have a separate deductible.

Does not cover

Wear and maintenance

Insurance does not pay for roof maintenance or for replacing it due to wear, according to the Maryland Insurance Administration. If the roof is old, this shows.

Watch out

Old roofs

Some insurers pay only actual cash value after a certain age; for example, an insurer cited by the Missouri Department of Insurance settles roofs 11 years or older at actual cash value. Check your policy: it is one case, not a rule.

Sources: NAIC (above), Maryland Insurance Administration (undated) and Missouri Department of Insurance (an insurer’s fact sheet, undated).

From here to a decision

1Document2Prevent more damage3Notify4Inspection5Decision1–10 days6Payment30–60 daysTypical timelines according to Angi, after the inspection
  1. Document the damage with photos or video before cleaning up, and keep receipts. (NAIC and Angi)
  2. Prevent further damage with reasonable temporary repairs, such as covering a hole in the roof; keep the receipts, because insurance usually reimburses them. (NAIC)
  3. Notify your insurer promptly. Most have deadlines for reporting; the sources give no specific deadline, so check yours. (NAIC)
  4. Meet the adjuster. The company’s adjuster inspects at no cost to you; Angi advises having your own contractor present so nothing is overlooked.
  5. Wait for the decision, which Angi places between 1 and 10 days after the inspection. Do not start major work before it approves.
  6. Get paid: about 30 to 60 days, and if there is a mortgage the payment may be issued in your name and the bank’s (NAIC).

Sources: Angi, storm damage claim (undated) and NAIC, after the storm (September 1, 2018).

How the payment usually works

Using the NAIC’s example, a $15,000 storm loss with a $1,000 deductible pays $14,000 under a replacement cost policy. With actual cash value, depreciation comes off first. If the roof had lost, say, $6,000 of its value to age (an illustrative number, not from the NAIC), the payment would be $15,000 minus $6,000 minus $1,000, or $8,000, and you would cover the rest. The gap is the reason the type of policy matters more than almost anything else on the page.

Some replacement cost policies pay in two steps, first the actual cash value and then the withheld depreciation once the work is done and you submit the invoices. Ask your insurer how yours works, because it affects how much you need to have available while the roof is being replaced.

Read the policy before the storm

  • Is the roof covered at replacement cost or actual cash value?
  • Is there a separate or percentage deductible for wind and hail?
  • Are there exclusions or reduced coverage for older roofs, or for certain materials?
  • What do you have to do, and by when, to file a claim?

Beware of contractors

After a storm, “free roof” offers appear. The Maryland Insurance Administration describes them as schemes in which wear is presented as storm damage, and warns that a contractor cannot file or negotiate your claim (in that state, only a licensed public adjuster). The NAIC adds that you do not have to sign an assignment of benefits to repair the roof: you can file the claim yourself and keep control of your policy. Ask for several quotes and references, and check the license.

A claim, step by step

  1. Make the house safe and prevent further damage, keeping receipts.
  2. Photograph and video everything before you clean up.
  3. Report the claim to your insurer promptly, and get the claim number.
  4. Let the adjuster inspect, and consider having your own roofer present or provide a written assessment.
  5. Review the estimate line by line, and ask what is covered and what is not.
  6. Get contractor quotes, and ask the insurer how supplements are handled if the contractor finds hidden damage.
  7. Keep invoices if the policy pays depreciation after the work is complete.

This page is general information, not insurance or legal advice, and every policy and state is different.

If you disagree with the decision

Angi mentions these routes: ask for a second adjuster, have an independent adjuster inspect the roof, hire a public adjuster (who charges a percentage of the settlement), escalate to a supervisor, consult an attorney or file a complaint. The NAIC adds that if the insurer does not respond in time or does not investigate reasonably, you can go to your state’s department of insurance.

Will filing a claim raise my premium?

It may, depending on the insurer and your state. If the damage is only slightly above your deductible, it can be worth asking your agent for guidance before you file.

How long does it take?

It varies widely, especially after a regional storm when adjusters and roofers are busy. Ask for timelines in writing and keep the temporary protection in place.

Is it a claim or a maintenance issue?

The sources agree that insurers generally do not pay for wear and tear. That is why the age and condition of the roof, and the date and cause of the damage, matter so much. Our guide on repair or replace helps you tell them apart.

If a claim leads to a new roof, compare prices in the cost calculator by state and review the questions in how to compare roofing quotes.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top