A metal roof costs more up front but lasts much longer, so the cost per year usually works out better; asphalt is cheaper and more common, but has to be replaced sooner. The energy savings from metal exist mostly in hot climates, but no source gives a reliable figure for a specific home.
Compare the cost per year of life: metal vs. asphalt
Our own calculation with HomeGuide installed costs per square foot (asphalt $3 to $6; metal by type). The starting lifespans (20 years for asphalt, 50 for metal) are our own choice within the sources’ ranges: change them. Cooling savings start at zero because no source gives a reliable figure for homes with metal. It does not include inflation, maintenance or the rising price of a future roof.
What each one costs
The sources do not agree much: HomeGuide gives narrower ranges than Angi for asphalt and much lower ones for metal. Angi goes as high as $135,000 for metal (with copper and other luxury metals) and an average of $22,000.
Sources: HomeGuide, metal roofing, Angi, metal vs. shingles and HomeGuide, replacing a roof.
How long they last
Sources: Angi, HomeGuide and NerdWallet (updated July 2025). NerdWallet puts asphalt at 20 to 25 years (3-tab) and about 30 (architectural); the chart shows the range from the other two sources.
And the energy savings, are they real?
A more reflective roof reflects more sun and heats the house less. Berkeley Lab estimates that raising roof reflectance from 20% (dark gray) to 55% (weathered white) can reduce cooling use by 20%. The EPA notes that these “cool” roofs can be 50–60°F cooler than conventional ones in the middle of summer, but that they also deflect some useful heat in winter, and that the net savings depend on the climate and the price of electricity. Those data are for reflective roofs in general, not metal versus asphalt on a house: we have not found a reliable source with a figure for that specific case.
Sources: Berkeley Lab (no study date) and EPA, cool roofs (2021 archive; cites studies from 1990 to 2004).
Quick comparison
| Aspect | Asphalt shingles | Metal roof |
|---|---|---|
| Installed cost | $5,700 to $12,000 (HomeGuide); average of $10,500 (Angi) | $7,500 to $40,000 (HomeGuide); average of $22,000 (Angi) |
| Per square foot | $3 to $6 (HomeGuide) | $5 to $16 (HomeGuide) |
| Lifespan | 15 to 30 years | 30 to 80 years or more |
| Average repair | About $975 (Angi) | About $1,700 (Angi) |
| Insurance | — | May reduce premiums (HomeGuide), no figure |
| Noise | — | Little, if well installed and insulated (HomeGuide) |
| Resale value | — | Higher return than asphalt, according to Angi and HomeGuide, no figure |
Cost per year of life
The cleanest way to compare is to divide price by years. Using Angi’s averages, $10,500 for asphalt and $22,000 for metal, and the middle of the lifespan ranges, 25 years for asphalt and 50 for metal, you get roughly $420 a year against $440 a year. That is nearly a tie, and the real answer depends on where you land in the ranges. The best case for metal (HomeGuide’s low price of $7,500 over 80 years) is under $100 a year, while the worst (the high $40,000 over 30 years) is above $1,300 a year. Asphalt runs from about $190 a year (the low price over 30 years) to $800 (the high price over 15). In other words, metal wins clearly only if you stay long enough for its lifespan to matter, which is the point of the “which suits your case” section.
Other trade-offs the numbers hide
- Sound. Metal can be louder in heavy rain unless the roof has solid decking and underlayment.
- Denting. Some metals can dent in hail, and the finish matters. Ask about the gauge and the warranty.
- Installers. Asphalt is far more common, so you will usually find more contractors who do it well.
- Resale. The sources we reviewed do not quantify the effect on sale price, so we do not rely on it.
Which one suits your case
If you are staying many years
With a lifespan of 30 to 80 years according to the sources versus 15 to 30 for asphalt, this is where the cost per year works out best, even if the initial price is higher.
If you sell soon or have a tight budget
It costs less up front ($5,700 to $12,000 according to HomeGuide) and is the most common material. Angi notes that it needs more maintenance and repairs.
Cold and hot climates
Angi says metal can lower cooling costs in hot climates, and that in cold climates asphalt can be more efficient, although metal with an air gap can match the insulation.
If you are going to install solar panels, the roof should last as long as they do: our article on how long solar panels last helps you see whether it pays to replace the roof first.
The solar angle
If you plan to install solar, the roof underneath should outlast the panels. That favors a material with a long life, and it also means replacing a roof before putting panels on it, not after. Our guides on roof lifespan and solar shingles versus panels explain more.
How to decide
- Work out how many years you plan to stay in the house: if it is only a few, asphalt is usually enough.
- Ask for quotes on both materials with tear-off, decking and warranties separated.
- Ask the contractor about the type of metal (panels, standing seam or metal shingles), which changes the price a lot.
- Call your insurer: HomeGuide says metal can reduce premiums, but it depends on each company.
- Use the calculator above with your own lifespans and your cooling savings, if you know them.
Does a metal roof really save on cooling?
A reflective roof can: Berkeley Lab estimates that raising reflectance from 20% to 55% can reduce cooling use by 20%, but that applies to any reflective roof, not just metal, and depends on the climate.
Can metal go over existing shingles?
Sometimes, depending on local rules and the roof’s condition, but ask the contractor whether tear-off is needed. It is a question to settle in writing before the quote.
For prices by size and place, see the cost per square foot and the cost calculator by state, and for climate fit, roofing materials by climate.
Our summary
Metal is a long-term choice and asphalt is a practical one. If you plan to stay for decades, want the longest-lasting option or are planning solar, metal can make the most sense. If you may sell in a few years, or your budget is tight, asphalt is a reasonable choice when it carries the right rating for your climate. Ask for both quotes, with the same scope, and compare the cost per year of life.
Worth reading alongside this one: Roof Replacement Cost Calculator by State.
