Heating and cooling is the largest single use of energy in most homes, and the equipment that does it is among the most expensive and the least visible: you notice it only when it breaks, usually in the hottest or coldest week of the year. This guide helps you plan before that happens. It explains what each type of system costs to install and to run, how to choose between a heat pump, a furnace, central air and a mini-split, how to size equipment correctly and how to get a quote you can trust.
Prices come from published sources, mostly PickHVAC, EnergySage and CBS News, and from ENERGY STAR for efficiency. Quotes vary widely, from about $5,000 to $28,000 for the same type of job according to CBS News, so these are guides for evaluating quotes, not substitutes for them.
What the system is made of, and what you are really buying
A home heating and cooling system has three parts: the equipment that makes heat or cold (a furnace, a heat pump, an air conditioner), the distribution that moves it through the house (ducts or refrigerant lines to wall units) and the controls, from a basic thermostat to a connected one. When you ask for a quote on “a new system,” most of the cost is in the first two parts, and a lot of the variation between bids is in the second.
The main options are these. A gas furnace burns fuel to heat air, and is usually paired with a separate air conditioner for summer. An electric furnace uses resistance heating. A heat pump moves heat instead of making it, which is why it can deliver more than one unit of heat per unit of electricity, and it can heat and cool with the same equipment. Central air cools through ducts. A ductless mini-split uses an outdoor unit with one or more indoor units on the wall, with no ducts at all.
What it costs to install
Our HVAC replacement article puts the usual cost of replacing a furnace and air conditioner at $7,000 to $12,000 according to PickHVAC, with quotes from $5,000 to $28,000 reported by CBS News. For a standard system, price grows with the size of the house, at about $3 to $6 per square foot. A heat pump system is more expensive on average, at $14,353 according to EnergySage, but for many homes it replaces two machines with one.
Air conditioner replacement by size
| Size | Capacity (BTU) | Home area (sq ft) | Typical installed cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5 ton | 18,000 | 600–900 | $2,000 to $5,000 |
| 2 ton | 24,000 | 1,000–1,300 | $2,500 to $5,500 |
| 2.5 ton | 30,000 | 1,300–1,600 | $2,700 to $6,000 |
| 3 ton | 36,000 | 1,600–1,900 | $3,000 to $6,500 |
Source: PickHVAC ranges in our air conditioner replacement calculator.
Efficiency raises the price: moving from a 13 to 14 SEER unit ($2,500 to $6,000) to a 17 to 18 SEER unit ($3,500 to $8,600) adds about $1,000 at the low end and up to $2,600 at the high end. Units rated 19 to 21 SEER cost $4,000 to $10,000, and 22 to 26 SEER $6,000 to $11,000. Permits of $250 to $1,500 and removal of the old unit of $50 to $200 are often extra.
Ductwork: the budget breaker
The most common surprise in a heating and cooling bid is the duct system. If the ducts are in good condition they can be reused. If not, replacing them costs $10 to $50 per linear foot, and a job of more than 100 feet runs $5,000 to $12,000. Building ducts from scratch in a home that has none can add as much as $18,000 according to PickHVAC, which is one reason ductless systems are popular in older houses.
What it costs to run
Installation is a one-time cost; the energy bill is forever. The way to compare fuels fairly is to calculate the cost of the same amount of heat, for example 100,000 BTU. This is our own arithmetic, using $0.16 per kWh for electricity and $1.30 per therm for gas, the same values we use in our heat pump vs. furnace comparison.
| Heating source | Efficiency | Cost of 100,000 BTU |
|---|---|---|
| Gas furnace | 95% efficient | $1.37 |
| Heat pump | COP 3.4 (mild weather) | $1.38 |
| Heat pump | COP 2.0 (very cold weather) | $2.34 |
| Electric resistance | COP 1 | $4.69 |
The pattern is clear. In mild weather a heat pump costs about the same to run as an efficient gas furnace at these prices. In very cold weather its efficiency drops and gas is cheaper, unless electricity is cheap. Electric resistance heat, such as baseboards or an electric furnace, is the most expensive way to heat by a wide margin. Your own result depends on your local prices, so replace the two prices with your real ones before you rely on the table.
For cooling, the number to look at is SEER (or SEER2 on newer labels). A higher rating uses less electricity for the same cooling, but it costs more to buy, and the extra price pays back only if you cool a lot. Our replacement calculator shows whether a higher rating pays for itself for your house.
Heat pump, furnace plus air conditioner, or something else?
This is the question most homeowners have to answer, and the answer depends on what you have now, your climate and your fuel prices. Our full comparison works through four common situations; this is the short version.
Replacing electric resistance heat
A heat pump almost always saves money, because it delivers several times more heat per kWh than resistance heating does.
Replacing a gas furnace in a mild climate
Running costs are similar, so the decision turns on installation price, available incentives and whether you also need a new air conditioner. A heat pump covers both.
Replacing a gas furnace in a cold climate
A cold-climate heat pump, sometimes with a backup source, can work, but running costs may be higher than gas. Check the equipment’s rated output at your coldest temperatures.
A heat pump with an air conditioner plus furnace costs about $500 to $2,000 less than a gas furnace and a new air conditioner, which cost $9,500 to $19,000 together, according to our comparison. And whichever system you choose, an experienced installer matters: EnergySage notes that a poor installation can perform 20% to 30% worse than the same equipment installed well. See also air-source heat pump cost and savings by climate for the numbers by climate zone.
Central air or a ductless mini-split
If your house has good ducts, central air is usually the cheaper way to cool it: PickHVAC puts central air with existing ductwork at $3,000 to $7,000 in an average home. If it has no ducts, or the ducts need to be replaced, a mini-split can win. Our central air vs. mini-split comparison uses a mini-split price of $1,800, $3,500 or $6,500 per zone (low, mid and high range) and compares it with ducts at $10, $25 or $50 per linear foot.
Mini-splits are efficient: they can use about 30% less energy to cool a home, and cost 20% to 40% less to run for the same comfort, according to the sources in that article. A summer bill of $100 a month with central air could drop to between $60 and $80. The trade-off is the look of the indoor units and the cost per zone, which grows as you add rooms. For a house with only one or two rooms that need conditioning, a mini-split is often the better choice, and for a house that needs cooling in every room, central air is often cheaper.
Getting the size right
Bigger is not better. An oversized air conditioner cools the house quickly, then shuts off before it has removed the humidity, leaving the air cool and damp, and it cycles on and off, which wears the equipment and wastes energy. An undersized one runs without stopping on the hottest days and never reaches the temperature you set. Our air conditioner size calculator starts with the ENERGY STAR table for one room and shows how to add tons for the whole house.
Square footage is only a first guess. The cooling load of two homes of the same size in different places can differ by 30% to 50%, for example a house in Santa Monica compared with one in Palm Springs. A proper load calculation looks at insulation, windows, orientation, air leakage and the ducts, and a contractor who skips it and quotes by “the size of what you have now” is guessing. Ask every bidder whether they will do a load calculation, and ask to see it.
The best way to shrink the equipment you need is to improve the house first. Better insulation and windows reduce the load, so a smaller and cheaper system does the job. See how much insulation you need and the upgrade payback calculator to compare the order in which to do things.
Why the summer bill spikes, and what to do about it
If your electric bill jumps in summer, the air conditioner is usually the cause, but it is not the only one. EnergySage puts summer consumption 25% to 35% above the annual average. Our article on why the electric bill is so high in summer lists nine causes, and one lesson is to read your bill in three numbers: the days in the billing period, the kWh used and the kWh per day. A July bill that covers 35 days and 1,300 kWh costs $194 against $134 for a June bill of 30 days and 900 kWh; the bill is 44% higher, but daily use rose only about 24%, and the rest comes from the five extra days.
Before you replace anything, check the cheap things: filters, the thermostat settings, blocked vents, ducts that leak into the attic and the age of the equipment. Air conditioners, water heaters and refrigerators lose efficiency after 10 to 15 years, so the age of the unit is a clue to whether replacement will lower the bill.
Thermostats, timing and when to replace
A smart thermostat is the smallest upgrade and has been oversold. ENERGY STAR’s average is 8% of the heating and cooling bill, about $50 a year. At a price of $150 (an illustrative figure) that pays back in about three years, and a $250 one in five. The savings come from setbacks: lowering the thermostat 7 to 10 degrees for eight hours a day can save up to 10% a year on heating and cooling. A cheaper programmable thermostat that you actually use can do the same job, and a connected one that you override all the time saves nothing. Read whether a smart thermostat is worth it before you buy.
As for timing, the best time to replace a system is before it fails, in the season when contractors are less busy. Our best time of year to replace an HVAC system describes the price calendar month by month and gives a planning timeline for an aging system. If the system is older than its expected life and repairs are mounting, start getting quotes in the shoulder season instead of waiting for a July breakdown.
How to get a quote you can trust
- Ask for a load calculation and the size and efficiency rating of the proposed equipment, in writing.
- Get at least three quotes for the same scope: equipment, ducts, permits, removal, thermostat and warranty.
- Compare models and ratings, not brand names alone; the same brand has several lines with different efficiency.
- Ask about the ducts: will they be tested, sealed, modified or replaced?
- Check licenses and insurance and ask for local references from similar jobs.
- Look at warranties, both the manufacturer’s on the equipment and the contractor’s on the labor.
- Ask what incentives remain in your state or utility area before you sign, and have the contractor explain how they apply.
Be careful with a very low price: it may leave out the permit, the duct work or the removal of the old equipment. And be careful with a very high one: ask what makes it different from the others in a way you can verify.
A budget example for a 1,800 square foot house
Numbers are easier to follow with a case. Take a house of 1,800 square feet that needs a standard furnace and air conditioner. At $3 to $6 per square foot, the rule of thumb in our replacement cost article, the system costs about 1,800 × $3 = $5,400 at the low end and 1,800 × $6 = $10,800 at the high end. That is our own multiplication and it sits in the same area as the $7,000 to $12,000 usual range.
Now add what that rule of thumb does not include. A gas furnace replacement can need gas line adjustments of $200 to $800 and flue changes of $300 to $1,500, according to PickHVAC. Permits of $250 to $1,500 and removal of the old unit at $50 to $200 are often separate. If 100 feet of ducts must be replaced at $10 to $50 per foot, that adds $1,000 to $5,000. A sensible budget therefore starts from the middle of the range and keeps a reserve of 10% to 15% for the things nobody sees until the old equipment comes out. When a quote is far below your own estimate, the reserve is how you find out what is missing.
Keeping the system running well
A well-installed system that is never maintained will not reach its expected life. Most of what matters is simple and cheap.
- Change or clean the filter on the schedule the manufacturer gives, usually every one to three months in the seasons of heavy use. A clogged filter forces the fan to work harder and reduces airflow.
- Keep the outdoor unit clear of leaves, grass and snow, with at least a couple of feet of space around it.
- Schedule a yearly check before the season of heavy use. A technician looks at refrigerant, electrical connections, the condensate drain and the coils.
- Do not close many vents to “save” energy; it raises the pressure in the ducts and can make leaks and noise worse.
- Know the signs of trouble: weak airflow, strange noises, short cycling, ice on the lines, uneven rooms or a bill that climbs without a change in use.
Heat pumps are used all year, so they benefit even more from regular attention. Keep your records, because many manufacturers ask for proof of maintenance when you make a warranty claim.
Comfort, humidity and air quality
Two homes with the same temperature setting can feel completely different, and the reason is usually humidity and air movement, not the equipment’s headline rating. An oversized air conditioner leaves the air damp, as the sizing section explained. A system with leaky ducts can pull dusty air from the attic or crawl space, and rooms at the end of a long duct run may never reach the set temperature. Sealing and insulating the ducts is one of the improvements most likely to make a house feel better without changing the equipment. If you are replacing the system, ask the contractor to test the airflow and the duct leakage and to show you the results.
A good installer will also talk about the filter, the ventilation and the thermostat location: a thermostat in a hallway or in direct sun controls the whole house from the wrong place. These details cost very little during an installation and are hard to correct afterwards.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Replacing like for like without checking whether the old system was the right size to begin with.
- Choosing only on price, when two bids rarely cover the same work.
- Buying the highest efficiency without checking whether you use the system enough for it to pay back.
- Ignoring the ducts, which can waste a large part of the energy the equipment produces.
- Waiting for a breakdown, which leaves no time to compare and puts you at the mercy of the first available contractor.
- Skipping the insulation, when improving the house first could allow smaller equipment.
The common thread is planning. A system that is bought after a few weeks of comparison is nearly always a better purchase than one bought in a heat wave.
Incentives and how to find them
Incentives for efficient heating and cooling change often, and the rules differ by state and by utility, so any list printed here would be out of date soon. The reliable way to find what is available is to ask three places: your electric or gas utility, your state energy office and the contractor, who should be able to tell you which programs apply to the equipment they are proposing. Ask in writing, ask whether the incentive is paid to you or deducted from the bid, and find out whether the equipment must meet a specific rating to qualify, because choosing a model that is one level below can cost you the rebate. Our state rebates and incentives guide explains where to look, and why it is worth checking before you buy rather than after.
Frequently asked questions
How much does a new heating and cooling system cost?
PickHVAC puts replacing a standard furnace and air conditioner at $7,000 to $12,000, though quotes range from about $5,000 to $28,000. A heat pump system averages $14,353 according to EnergySage.
Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace?
In mild weather the cost is about the same at our example prices; in very cold weather gas can be cheaper. It also depends on your local electricity and gas prices.
How long does an HVAC system last?
Furnaces commonly last 15 to 20 years and electric furnaces can last 20 to 30 years. Air conditioners and heat pumps lose efficiency as they age, so the cost to run them rises over time.
What size air conditioner do I need?
For a whole house, the size depends on a load calculation, not just on square feet. As a rough guide, 1.5 tons covers 600 to 900 square feet and 3 tons covers 1,600 to 1,900 square feet.
Are smart thermostats worth it?
On average they save about 8% of the heating and cooling bill according to ENERGY STAR, roughly $50 a year, so the payback is a few years if you use the features.
When is the best time to replace a system?
Before it fails, and in the shoulder seasons when contractors are less busy and prices are often better.
To work out your own numbers, start with the HVAC replacement cost guide, then use the air conditioner calculator and the sizing calculator. If you are choosing between technologies, read heat pump vs. furnace, central air vs. mini-split and heating installation costs. The figures come from PickHVAC, EnergySage, CBS News, ENERGY STAR and the other sources named in each linked article. They are estimates for general information, not a quote or professional advice. Read how we research and update our guides.
