How to Compare Roofing Quotes: Red Flags and Key Questions

Offer A Offer B Offer C!

To compare roofing quotes, ask for at least three in writing, compare like with like (material, scope, permits, warranties) and be wary of a very low price, a large deposit, pressure to hurry and a missing contract. These are the questions and red flags recommended by the FTC, Owens Corning and Angi.

3 quotesAt a minimum, in writing, according to Angi
15% or lessDeposit that Angi considers reasonable
3 referencesFrom previous customers, according to Angi
In writingThe contract and all promises, according to the FTC

Roofing quote comparison tool

Example values: replace them with those from your offers.

Check what each offer includes in writing:

ItemABC
Verified license (if your state requires it)
Liability insurance
Workers’ compensation insurance
Materials with brand, line and color
Detailed scope, tear-off, disposal and cleanup
Permits and their cost
Start and end dates
Itemized costs and payment schedule
Manufacturer warranty
Workmanship warranty
Notice of possible extras for hidden damage

Our own calculation. The items come from what Owens Corning and Angi say a quote should include, and the 15% threshold is the one Angi cites as a reasonable deposit; each state may have its own rules. It is an aid for comparing, not an assessment of each contractor.

What a good quote should include

It should includeWhy it matters
Materials: brand, line and colorTo compare like with like
Detailed scope and removal of the old materialTear-off, disposal and site cleanup
Permits and their costWho handles them and how much they cost
License, liability and workers’ compensation insuranceProtects the home and the workers
Start and end datesAnd what could delay them
Itemized costs and payment schedulePayment methods and possible extras if hidden damage appears
Manufacturer and workmanship warrantyWith the conditions to keep them valid

Source: Owens Corning (October 30, 2026), with Angi (undated). A shingle manufacturer, like Owens Corning, is an interested party in the industry.

How to compare them

  • Compare like with like. One quote may be for a full replacement and another for a simple repair (Owens Corning).
  • Count the extras. The contractor’s distance, steep roofs, underlayment, ventilation vents or a skylight change the price and must appear in writing (Owens Corning).
  • Review both warranties, the manufacturer’s and the workmanship one, not just the price (Owens Corning).
  • If the quote is digital, ask how they measured, whether there will be a visit to verify and whether it covers repairing the decking (Owens Corning).
  • Ask for separate quotes to repair and to replace if you are torn between the two options (Owens Corning).

Key questions for each contractor

  • What is your license number, and does my state require roofers to be licensed? Angi reminds readers that not all states require it; in that case, ask for proof of their experience.
  • Can you give me proof of liability and workers’ compensation insurance, and is it current? (Angi, Owens Corning, FTC)
  • What warranty do you offer on your work, and what manufacturer warranty is included? (Angi, Owens Corning)
  • When is each part paid and by what means? Agree on the schedule before starting (Angi, Owens Corning).
  • Who handles the permits? (Owens Corning; Angi is wary of anyone who asks you to get them yourself.)
  • Can you give me at least three references from previous customers? Ask them whether the budget and the deadlines were respected (Angi).
  • What happens if hidden damage appears when the old roof is removed? (Owens Corning)

Red flags

Red flagWhat the sources say
Shows up after a storm without you callingUnlicensed contractors who contact you after a weather event are a red flag (FTC); “storm chasers” offer “free” inspections and may take a deposit and disappear (Angi)
No written contractThe FTC and Angi ask for the contract and all promises in writing
Demands payment in full up frontMay do poor work or none at all (FTC)
Large depositAngi cites “15% or less” as reasonable
Only cash, gift cards, wire transfers, apps or cryptocurrencySign of a scam (FTC); Angi is also wary of cash
Price far below the othersMay imply cuts in materials, installation, license, insurance or warranty (Owens Corning); often goes up during the job (Angi)
Rush to sign before comparingHigh-pressure sales (Angi)
Asks you to pull the permits yourselfMay indicate they cannot get them (Angi)
Exaggerated or vague damageInflated or unclear findings (Angi)
No license, insurance, reviews or track recordAsk for the license number, proof of current insurance and look at reviews from several sources (FTC, Angi)
Assignment of checks or insurance benefitsDo not sign over checks or an assignment of benefits (AoB) at the start; nor accept that they will cover your deductible (Angi)

Sources: FTC (May 2024, modified September 2024; it deals with contractors after emergencies in general, not just roofs), Angi (undated) and Owens Corning.

A grid you can fill in for each bid

  • Company name, license number and insurance proof.
  • Material: brand, product line, color and warranty.
  • Scope: tear-off, decking repair, underlayment, flashing, vents.
  • Permits: included or extra, and who pulls them.
  • Start date, expected duration and what happens if weather delays the job.
  • Cleanup and disposal of old material.
  • Payment schedule and total price.
  • Workmanship warranty, in years, and in writing.

Put the quotes side by side and look for blanks. A blank is either something left out or something to ask about.

Two warranties, not one

The manufacturer’s warranty covers the material, usually for a long period but with conditions. The contractor’s workmanship warranty covers the installation, which is where most leaks begin. Ask how long each lasts, who honors it, and whether it transfers if you sell the house.

Payment and contract

  • Pay by check or card, not cash, and if you can, by credit card after the work is finished (FTC, Angi).
  • Do not pay the final balance or sign the completion certificate until you are satisfied with the work (Angi).
  • Do not sign if the price, scope, timeline, materials, permits, payment schedule, change and cancellation terms, license and insurance are missing (Angi). Angi also advises avoiding agreements that tie you exclusively to one contractor.
  • If you suspect a scam, the FTC points to ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

Deposits and payment schedules

The FTC and Angi advise paying by check or card and not in cash, and holding back the final payment until you are satisfied. A common structure is a small deposit, a payment when materials arrive and a final payment after the work, but rules on deposits vary by state, so check yours. A large deposit up front, especially from a contractor who arrived unasked after a storm, is a red flag. Before you sign, make sure the contract states the total price, the scope and the dates.

If the roof is paid for by insurance

Angi advises calling your insurer first so the adjuster can inspect the damage, because starting earlier could get the claim denied, and recommends not signing over checks or insurance rights at the start. For more detail, see our article on claims.

Putting it into practice

  • Ask for at least three written quotes with the same material and the same scope.
  • Check the license (if your state requires it), insurance and reviews from several sources.
  • Fill in the comparison tool above and review what is missing from each offer.
  • Ask about what is missing and request the corrections in writing before signing.
  • Sign a complete contract, pay a reasonable deposit and keep everything in writing.
How do I check a contractor’s reputation?

Look at reviews from several sources, ask for recent local references, and check your state’s licensing board where one exists. Seeing a recent job in person helps.

Is the cheapest bid the best?

Not by itself. If a price is well below the others, compare the scope: it may leave out tear-off, decking or permits. Our price-per-square-foot guide shows typical ranges.

What if damage came from a storm?

Contact your insurer before signing anything; see how insurance claims work.

To know whether you need a repair or a full replacement, read repair or replace.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top