Solar Shingles vs. Solar Panels on Your Roof

Panels Solar shingles

Solar panels are cheaper, more efficient and have more installers; solar shingles blend into the roof and look more discreet, but cost more and produce less. The sources suggest that shingles usually only pay off when the roof has to be replaced anyway and appearance matters more than price.

Solar panels or solar shingles for your roof?

Power with panels–
Power with shingles–
Guidance–

Our own calculation. Power uses 20 W per sq ft for panels and 16 W per sq ft for shingles (Angi, solar shingle guide). The cost of panels uses $2.50 to $3.50 per watt and that of shingles “up to $9” per watt (This Old House, which gives no minimum). The sources do not agree with each other on total costs: the figure is only an order of magnitude.

Quick comparison

AspectSolar panelsSolar shingles
Price per watt$2.50 to $3.50 (This Old House)Up to $9 (This Old House)
Total cost$18,400 to $36,400 (Angi)$21,000 to $50,000 (Angi)
Efficiency17% to 20%, some up to 24% (This Old House)14% to 18% (This Old House)
Power per sq ftAbout 20 W (Angi)About 16 W (Angi)
Lifespan25 to 30 years (This Old House)Up to 30 years according to manufacturers, with no real-world data (This Old House, Angi)
Product warrantyNot citedAbout 25 years on average (This Old House)
InstallationOn racking above the roof, with adjustable tiltIntegrated into the roof; usually requires replacing it entirely
InstallersManyFew (This Old House)
AspectMore visibleDiscreet, although still black or blue (Angi)
If you moveCan be removed and taken with you (Angi)Stay with the house (Angi)

Sources: This Old House (updated June 1, 2026), Angi: comparison (undated) and Angi: solar shingles (undated).

What it costs in total

$0$20,000$40,000$60,000$80,000Total installation cost (dollars)Panels · Angi$18,400–$36,400Shingles · Angi (comparison)$21,000–$50,000Shingles · Angi (guide)$60,000–$75,000
Two Angi pages (both undated) give very different figures for solar shingles: $21,000 to $50,000 in its comparison and $60,000 to $75,000 in its shingle guide, where it talks about $20 to $25 per sq ft. Actual costs depend on the size of the house and the system.

That is why the totals are best treated as an order of magnitude and you should ask for quotes: solar shingles are the most expensive option in every source, but there is no agreement on how much.

Efficiency, lifespan and durability

  • Efficiency. This Old House gives 17% to 20% for panels and 14% to 18% for shingles. Angi cites the U.S. Department of Energy with new panels “around 23%” and up to 27%: the panel figures do not match between sources.
  • Lifespan. Panels, 25 to 30 years. Shingles, up to 30 years according to manufacturers, but This Old House and Angi agree that there is not yet any real long-term data.
  • Durability. Panels withstand rain, hail and wind (This Old House). Angi says shingles withstand weather and debris better.
  • Cleaning. Both need cleaning about twice a year, and shingles are harder to clean and to clear of snow (This Old House).

The federal tax credit is no longer available

The IRS states that the residential clean energy credit covered installations placed in service from 2022 to 2025 and that it is not available for property placed in service after December 31, 2025. Solar shingles and panels qualified; traditional roofing materials and structural elements generally did not. The credit is nonrefundable, but the unused portion can carry forward to future years, according to the IRS. This only helps if you claim it for an installation made no later than 2025: for installations now, also look at incentives from your state or your utility.

Sources: IRS (reviewed July 4, 2026) and Rewiring America (undated).

What it means in dollars per system

This Old House puts panels at $2.50 to $3.50 per watt and shingles at up to $9. For a 6 kW system, that is roughly $15,000 to $21,000 for panels and up to $54,000 for shingles (our own multiplication). Angi’s totals, $18,400 to $36,400 for panels and $21,000 to $50,000 for shingles, are lower at the top end. The sources do not agree, which is why we recommend getting quotes for both on the same roof and the same system size.

Note that a shingle system is partly a roof as well as a power plant, so its price should be compared with panels plus the cost of the roofing that they sit on. If your roof needs replacing anyway, the gap narrows.

Timing with the roof

Putting panels on a roof that will need replacing soon means paying to remove and reinstall them later. If your roof has many years of life left, panels are the logical option. If it is due for replacement, it is the best moment to compare shingles with a new roof plus panels. Our guides on roof lifespan and roofing materials by climate can help you judge.

When each one makes sense

  • Panels: if the roof is recent, if you want the best balance of price and power or if you want many installers to choose from.
  • Solar shingles: if you are already going to replace the roof, appearance is a priority and you accept a higher price and less long-term data.
  • The same roof with both: it is possible, but it can undercut the aesthetic effect of the shingles (This Old House).

Other points to weigh

  • Installers. Panels have many installers; shingles have few, which may limit your choices and quotes.
  • Appearance and rules. A homeowners association or historic district may favor the discreet look of shingles.
  • Repairs. Ask who is responsible if a leak appears, and how the roof and solar warranties interact.
  • Production. Lower efficiency means you need more area for the same power.

Before you commit

  1. Find out the condition and age of your roof: if it has useful life left, panels are usually the logical option.
  2. Calculate the usable roof area and use the calculator above as guidance.
  3. Ask for quotes for panels and for shingles, with the price per watt, the warranty and who is responsible if there are leaks.
  4. Ask about incentives from your state or your utility, now that the federal credit has ended.
  5. Check that the installer has experience with the product they propose, especially with shingles.
Is there still a federal credit?

No. The IRS says the residential clean energy credit covers property placed in service through December 31, 2025, so check state and utility programs.

How do I pay for either one?

See buying, leasing and financing compared. For an estimate of the total, use the solar cost calculator by state.

The short version

Solar panels are the safer default: cheaper per watt, more efficient and installed by many more companies. Solar shingles earn their place when you are replacing the roof anyway, appearance matters a lot to you or a homeowners association, and you accept paying more for less power. Whichever you choose, get quotes for the same roof and the same output so the comparison is fair, and ask how the roof warranty and the solar warranty work together if something leaks.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top