A smart thermostat can pay off, but only if you really save: the official average is 8% of the heating and cooling bill, manufacturers promise much more, and a field study with real households found no savings on average. The difference is in how you use it.
How many years until you recover what the thermostat costs?
Our own calculation. The $1,200 bill and the $200 cost are the illustrative example from ConsumerAffairs (October 2026), not averages; the 8% is the ENERGY STAR average. Enter your actual bill and your price. If the real savings are zero, it is never recovered.
What is promised and what was measured
The savings advertised by manufacturers come from their own studies, with comparisons that start from different assumptions. ENERGY STAR uses real data from many homes and gives an average. And an independent randomized experiment measured something considerably less optimistic.
Sources: ENERGY STAR, smart thermostat FAQ, Brandon, Clapp, List, Metcalfe and Price (UChicago BFI, 2022) and ACHR News (October 2024).
| Source | What it says | How it knows |
|---|---|---|
| ENERGY STAR | Average of 8% of the heating and cooling bill, about $50 a year | Field data from many homes, reviewed by an outside certifier; not a guarantee and varies by climate |
| Manufacturers (Nest, ecobee, Resideo) | From 8% up to 23-26% depending on the brand | Own or undetailed studies; the comparisons start from different assumptions |
| University of Chicago study (2022) | No average electricity savings and a 4.2% increase in gas; savings of about 10% in gas only among those who scheduled heavily | Randomized experiment with about 1,385 California households; 2012 and 2013 data with a Honeywell thermostat |
Why they save so little in practice
The study itself points to behavior: those who frequently overrode their schedules saved nothing, and those who followed them saved about 10% on gas. A smart thermostat does not save by itself: it saves when it lowers the heat or raises the AC setting while you are away. There is an important caveat: the study is old (2012 and 2013), from California and with a single model, so current thermostats might behave differently.
When it pays off and when it does not
Home with varying schedules
If you are usually out at fixed hours and use scheduling, that is where it can save the most. In the field study, those who made heavy use of schedules saved about 10% on gas; those who frequently overrode their schedules saved nothing.
Climate with large seasonal differences
ENERGY STAR says homes with big temperature swings by season usually save more, and those in mild climates somewhat less.
If you get a discount
ConsumerAffairs notes that utility rebates can shorten the payback period. Ask yours.
Home always occupied
ENERGY STAR says homes occupied all the time tend to save less: there are fewer setback hours to take advantage of.
You already have a well-used programmable thermostat
If you already lower the temperature when you are away, the change may give little. The savings come from use, not from the device.
Heat pump
ENERGY STAR warns that variable-capacity heat pumps usually perform better with the thermostat the manufacturer recommends, and ConsumerAffairs warns that big setbacks can trigger electric backup heat.
A useful reference: the U.S. Department of Energy recommends, according to ConsumerAffairs, lowering the thermostat 7 to 10 degrees for eight hours a day to save up to 10% a year on heating and cooling. That can be done with an inexpensive, non-connected programmable thermostat.
A payback check you can run in a minute
ENERGY STAR’s average is 8% of the heating and cooling bill, about $50 a year. If a thermostat costs $150 (an illustrative price), $50 a year pays it back in about three years, and a $250 one in five. If your savings are only half the average, or zero, as in the field study when people overrode their schedules, it never pays back. Utilities sometimes give discounts or free devices, which changes the math, so check before you buy.
Settings that do more than the gadget
The Department of Energy suggests lowering the thermostat 7 to 10 degrees for eight hours a day to save up to 10% a year on heating and cooling. A programmable thermostat can do that, and so can a smart one, and so can you with a manual dial if you remember. What matters is that the setback happens regularly, not what the device is called. If you were already doing it, a smart thermostat adds convenience more than savings.
How to decide
- Look at your annual heating and cooling bill: the savings are calculated on it.
- Ask your electric utility about smart thermostat rebates or giveaways.
- Check that the thermostat is compatible with your equipment, especially if you have a heat pump.
- If you decide to buy one, set real schedules and do not override them every day: that is where the savings are.
- With the calculator above, compare the price with savings of 0%, 4%, 8% and 10%.
Compatibility checklist
- Does your system have the wiring the thermostat needs? Many smart models need a common (C) wire.
- Is your system a heat pump, multi-stage equipment or an electric baseboard heater? These can need different thermostats.
- Does it work with your Wi-Fi and phone?
- Do you understand what data the app collects?
Why do manufacturers promise more than 8%?
Their numbers come from their own studies and different starting points, whereas ENERGY STAR uses real data from many homes. The independent field study found even less than the average.
Will it help if my bill is high in summer?
It can, if it lets the house warm up when nobody is home. Our guide to why summer bills are high looks at larger causes first.
To see where a thermostat ranks against other upgrades, use the energy savings calculator.
The takeaway
A smart thermostat is not a savings machine; it is a tool that makes saving easier if your routine fits it. If your schedule varies, you often forget to adjust the temperature, or your utility offers a discount, it can be a sensible purchase. If you already set back the temperature by hand, or your heating and cooling bill is small, the savings may not repay the cost for years. Check compatibility with your system before you buy, and judge the result after a full season, not a week.
Worth reading alongside this one: Why Is My Electric Bill So High in Summer? 9 Common Causes and Air-Source Heat Pump: Cost and Savings by Climate.
