Heat Pump vs. Air Conditioner Plus Furnace: Cost and Savings

A heat pump replaces both the furnace and the air conditioner, and installing it costs about the same as having both. What is not the same is what you pay each year: whether the heat pump saves money depends mostly on the climate, what electricity and gas cost where you live, and what you were heating with before. With cheap gas and lots of cold, it can cost you more.

$9,000 to $17,000Ducted heat pump, versus $9,500 to $19,000 for a furnace and air conditioner (PickHVAC)
$370 per yearAverage savings for households that switch, between $60 and $840 (EnergySage, using Rewiring America data)
$300 to $650 per yearMedian savings measured by NREL, according to EnergySage
Cheap gas and coldThe case where the heat pump usually costs more to run

Compare the heating cost of each system

Heat pump per year–
Gas furnace per year–
Difference per year–
Electricity price at which they tie–

PickHVAC method: the heat pump costs 293 × electricity price ÷ COP per million BTU and the furnace, 10 × gas price ÷ AFUE; this is multiplied by the season’s heating load (20, 40 or 70 million BTU depending on climate). The starting values are those of the source’s example. It calculates heating only, not hot water or air conditioning.

What it costs to install

On installation, the heat pump is often competitive. PickHVAC says it often matches or beats the cost of a furnace plus a new air conditioner, and EnergySage’s data agree if you count incentives, which are state or utility ones because the federal credit ended in 2025.

OptionInstalled costSource
Ducted heat pump$9,000 to $17,000PickHVAC (August 2025)
Cold-climate heat pump$11,000 to $20,000PickHVAC (August 2025)
Gas furnace and new air conditioner$9,500 to $19,000PickHVAC (August 2025)
Ducted heat pump (average)$14,529 ($13,527 with incentives)EnergySage, second half of 2025
Gas furnace and air conditioner$11,590 to $14,100EnergySage, third-party range
Hybrid heat pump (with backup furnace)$14,353 ($10,695 with incentives)EnergySage, second half of 2025

Sources: PickHVAC, heat pump vs. furnace and EnergySage, heat pump vs. air conditioner. These are each site’s estimates and they do not match each other.

What it costs to run

This is the part that changes. A heat pump moves heat instead of generating it, so it delivers several units of heat for every unit of electricity, but that efficiency (COP) drops when it is cold. This is PickHVAC’s illustrative example, with electricity at 0.16 dollars per kWh, gas at 1.30 dollars per therm and a 95% efficient furnace.

ClimateHeat pumpGas furnaceDifference
Warm (COP 3.4)$276$274+$2 with heat pump
Moderate (COP 2.8)$670$547+$123 with heat pump
Cold (COP 2.3)$1,427$958+$469 with heat pump
$0$400$800$1,200$1,600Annual heating cost (dollars, illustrative example)$276$274Warm$670$547Moderate$1,427$958ColdHeat pumpGas furnace
PickHVAC example; these are not measurements. The heat pump only matches the furnace in a warm climate at these prices.

If you change the prices, the result changes. With these same assumptions, PickHVAC calculates that electricity would have to cost about 0.16 dollars per kWh in a warm climate, 0.13 in a moderate one and 0.11 in a cold one for the heat pump to tie with gas. Try it in the calculator with your prices.

Savings depend on what you are replacing

The biggest savings come when you leave behind an expensive fuel: electric resistance, propane or heating oil. With natural gas, warm states save the most. These are EnergySage’s data, with its assumptions (winter COP of 2.5 and 80% efficient furnaces).

-10%0%20%40%60%80%Heating savings when switching to a heat pump (% of the bill)Electric resistanceapprox. 60%Propane22 to 74%Heating oil-3 to 54%Natural gas, warm states8 to 48%
Heating savings according to EnergySage. Natural gas, examples: Arkansas 48%, Texas 38%, Kentucky 27%, Arizona 26%, Georgia 24%, Kansas 8%. The propane and heating oil figures use 2024 prices.

Source: EnergySage, how much you save with a heat pump (June 2026). The source itself warns that the propane and heating oil prices are old.

Putting the two sides together

PickHVAC’s example shows the heat pump costing $2, $123 and $469 more per year than gas in warm, moderate and cold climates. Over a 15-year life (within the 15 to 20 years of a furnace), that adds up to about $30, $1,845 and $7,035 (our multiplication). Meanwhile, the installed price of a ducted heat pump ($9,000 to $17,000) is $500 to $2,000 below the range for a gas furnace plus a new air conditioner ($9,500 to $19,000). In a moderate climate, then, the extra running cost and the upfront saving are in the same ballpark, which is why local prices and incentives decide it. In a warm climate the heat pump is a clear candidate, and in a cold one, with cheap gas, the furnace usually wins on running cost.

Four common situations

Air conditioner is dying, furnace is fine

Compare a new air conditioner with a heat pump that also takes over heating later. Ask whether the new equipment can work with the existing furnace as a backup.

Both are old

This is the cleanest moment to compare a heat pump with a furnace plus air conditioner, since you are replacing both anyway.

You heat with oil, propane or electricity

The savings potential is largest here, according to EnergySage.

Cold winters and cheap gas

Do the running-cost comparison with your own prices before you decide.

When each option wins

Heat pump

Mild or warm climate

Also if you are replacing electricity, propane or heating oil, or if you need to replace the air conditioner anyway.

Gas furnace

Cold and cheap gas

In a cold climate with cheap gas, the heat pump usually costs more to run and sometimes more to install, even with incentives, according to EnergySage.

Hybrid

Heat pump with backup furnace

An option for cold regions with expensive electricity: the furnace kicks in when it is very cold. It costs $14,353 on average according to EnergySage.

On the cold: the U.S. Department of Energy says cold-climate heat pumps are designed to operate down to about 5°F, while EnergySage cites models that reach -23°F or lower. Each model’s figures vary: look at the datasheet and ask about its performance at the lowest temperature in your area.

And what about air conditioning?

In summer a heat pump works just like an air conditioner: according to EnergySage, cooling efficiency is the same. That is why the comparison comes down to heating. If your air conditioner is at the end of its life but the furnace is still good, replacing only the air conditioner can come out cheaper than replacing everything: compare both options with a quote.

How to decide

  1. Look at your actual electricity and gas prices on your bill and use them in the calculator above.
  2. Ask for quotes for a heat pump and for a furnace with a new air conditioner, with and without incentives.
  3. Ask about the heat pump’s performance at the lowest temperature in your area and whether it needs backup heat.
  4. Look for state and utility incentives on DSIRE: the federal credit no longer exists.
  5. Choose an experienced installer: EnergySage notes that a poor installation can perform 20% to 30% worse.
Do I need backup heat?

In cold climates many installers include it. Ask what it costs to run and when it turns on.

Will it also cool my house?

Yes, and as efficiently as an air conditioner, according to EnergySage.

For details on climate, see air-source heat pump cost and savings by climate, and for heating prices, heating installation cost. If you are replacing the cooling too, plan the timing with the best time to replace HVAC.

If this raised more questions, Air Conditioner Replacement Cost Calculator goes into more detail, and HVAC System Replacement Cost: What Drives the Price Up covers the next step.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top