An air-source heat pump takes heat from the outdoor air to warm your home, and it works well below freezing with today’s equipment. What changes with climate is not whether it works, but how efficiently it runs and how much you save: in a mild climate with mid-range electricity prices it usually works out well, and in a very cold one with cheap gas it can cost more than a furnace. Here is the data to know where you stand.
Compare an air-source heat pump with your current heating
PickHVAC method (August 2025): heat pump cost per million BTU = 293 × electricity price ÷ COP; with a fuel = price per million BTU ÷ efficiency. The load (20, 40 or 70 million BTU) and the COP for each climate are those from its example. The heating values of propane (about 91,500 BTU per gallon) and heating oil (about 138,500) are standard values worth checking. For propane and heating oil we do not set a starting price: use yours. It calculates heating only.
What to expect depending on your climate
The costs and efficiencies in this table are PickHVAC estimates; cold-climate equipment is designed for areas where temperatures regularly drop below freezing, according to ENERGY STAR.
| Climate | Equipment | Installed cost | What to watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Warm | Standard air-source heat pump | $9,000 to $17,000 | It is the most favorable case: mild winters and good efficiency (COP of 3.4 in PickHVAC’s example) |
| Moderate | Standard or cold-climate | $9,000 to $20,000 | Efficiency drops (COP of 2.8) and the result depends on the fuel you are replacing |
| Cold | Cold-climate heat pump, sometimes with backup | $11,000 to $20,000 | COP falls to 2.3; many homes add electric resistance heat or a backup furnace |
Source: PickHVAC, heat pump vs. furnace (August 2025). The “moderate” ranges are our own combination of the source’s two ranges.
Why efficiency matters so much
Efficiency (COP) says how many units of heat the heat pump delivers for every unit of electricity. It drops when it is cold. The chart shows how much it costs to produce the same amount of heat depending on that COP and on what you pay for electricity, compared with a gas furnace at PickHVAC’s example price.
That is why, with electricity at 0.16 dollars and gas at 1.30, the heat pump matches the furnace in a warm climate and loses in a cold one: it does not stop working, but its efficiency falls just when the most heat is needed.
The running cost, worked out
Take the article’s prices: electricity at $0.16 per kWh and gas at $1.30 per therm. A therm is 100,000 BTU of gas, and a kWh is 3,412 BTU of heat. To produce 100,000 BTU of heat:
- Gas furnace at 95% efficiency: $1.30 ÷ 0.95 = about $1.37.
- Heat pump at COP 3.4: 29.3 kWh ÷ 3.4 = 8.6 kWh, about $1.38.
- Heat pump at COP 2.0: 14.7 kWh, about $2.34.
- Electric resistance (COP 1): 29.3 kWh, about $4.69.
This is our own calculation, with an assumed furnace efficiency. It shows the pattern in the table: in a warm climate with COP above 3 the heat pump matches gas, and in a cold one, where COP falls toward 2, it costs more to run unless your electricity is cheap or your alternative is oil, propane or resistance heat.
What the research says about savings
An NREL study, published in the journal Joule in 2024 and based on simulations of 550,000 homes, estimates that between 62% and 95% of U.S. households would have a lower energy bill with an air-source heat pump, depending on its efficiency. With better insulation, the figure rises to 82% to 97%. Among the 49 million households that heat with electricity, heating oil or propane and have air conditioning, it would save between 92% and 100%, with median savings of $300 to $650 a year.
Source: American Public Power Association, on the NREL study (February 2024). Natural gas is cheaper than electricity per unit of energy in many areas, so savings are smaller there. Rewiring America, using NREL data, calculates average savings of $370 a year and says gas “does not save much on average” at current prices.
What we learned from the field
More where you replace expensive fuels
Rewiring America puts households with heating oil, propane or electric resistance at close to $1,000 a year in savings, and names Maine, Ohio, Pennsylvania, New York and Massachusetts as cold states where you can save a lot.
Tested down to 5°F
ENERGY STAR requires third-party testing down to 5°F for its cold-climate label, and recommends backup from another source at lower temperatures.
Real performance varies
EnergySage warns that a poor installation can perform 20% to 30% worse than expected, and that in cold climates with cheap gas the heat pump usually costs more to run.
NREL has published a field validation of cold-climate heat pumps (2023), but the summary gives no figures for cold-weather performance or savings. That is why this article uses ENERGY STAR datasheets and PickHVAC estimates for performance, and not a specific field measurement.
Things that matter besides the climate
- Capacity at low temperatures. Ask for the heating output at your coldest typical day, not just the rating at mild temperatures.
- Backup heat. Some homes keep a furnace or electric strips for the coldest hours. Ask what is included and what it costs to run.
- Ducted or ductless. Existing ducts in good condition favor a ducted system; otherwise see central air versus mini-split.
- Electrical capacity. A heat pump can add 30 to 60 A, so check your panel with the 200 amp panel guide.
How to choose well for your climate
- Find out your climate zone and the usual minimum temperature of your winter.
- Ask for ENERGY STAR cold-climate certified equipment if your winter regularly drops below freezing.
- Ask about each model’s efficiency and capacity at the lowest temperature in your area, on the datasheet.
- With your actual electricity and fuel prices, use the calculator above to see whether you come out ahead.
- Ask whether the system needs backup (electric resistance heat or a furnace) and how much it costs to add.
Does a heat pump stop working in freezing weather?
No. ENERGY STAR cold-climate models are designed for regular temperatures below freezing, but their efficiency falls, which is what the table shows.
Is it worth it if I have cheap gas?
Often the running cost will be similar or higher, so the case rests on cooling, incentives and what you pay for the old system. Run your own prices through the calculator.
For the full comparison with a furnace and air conditioner, read heat pump versus air conditioner plus furnace, and for the cost of heating systems, heating installation cost.
