Installing a heating system costs less than many people think if it is electric or gas, but that is only half the story: electric is the cheapest to install and the most expensive to run, gas is the middle ground, and a heat pump is the most expensive to install and is usually the cheapest to run where winters are mild. Here are the figures to compare the three.
Compare the 10-year cost of each heating system
Our own calculation: installation cost + 10 years of heating (undiscounted, no maintenance). The starting installation costs are PickHVAC averages (May 2026); the usage formula is PickHVAC’s. A heat pump also cools: if you choose gas or electric and need air conditioning, enter its cost here (in our article on replacing an air conditioner, PickHVAC gives $2,500 to $7,500).
What each system costs to install
These are PickHVAC’s installed costs (May 2026), which assume a single-family home with accessible ductwork, mid-efficiency equipment and residential-area labor.
Sources: PickHVAC, heating comparison (May 2026) and PickHVAC, cost of an HVAC system (May 2026). The source gives a single row for furnace and electric baseboards, and its description of the home is not the same throughout the page.
What they cost to run
Here the story changes. An electric resistance heater turns every kWh into heat at 100%, but electricity is usually more expensive than gas per unit of energy. A heat pump delivers several units of heat for every unit of electricity. For a moderate climate, with about 50 million BTU of heat a year and average U.S. prices, PickHVAC estimates these ranges.
Source: PickHVAC, cost of replacing an electric furnace (September 2025). These are illustrative figures: the source itself warns that climate and local rates change the result a lot.
What can raise the installation bill
The base price does not include what has to be adapted in your home. These are the most common items from PickHVAC.
| Item | Typical cost | When it comes up |
|---|---|---|
| Gas line adjustments | $200 to $800 | Shutoff, sediment trap or enlarging the pipe (gas furnace) |
| Changes to the flue | $300 to $1,500 | PVC, condensate drain or chimney liner |
| New electrical work | $300 to $4,000 or more | Dedicated circuit, subpanel or upgrading to 200 A (electric furnace or large heat pump) |
| Ductwork changes | $400 to $3,500 or more | If the ducts do not fit; replacing them entirely adds $2,000 to $8,000 |
| 240 V circuit for baseboards | $500 to $800 | Electric baseboard heating |
Thinking in ten years, not in installation day
Installation cost is the number in front of you, but running cost is the one you pay every winter. A furnace lasts 15 to 20 years with maintenance, according to PickHVAC, so a cheap-to-install, expensive-to-run system keeps costing you for most of that time. That is why the cost-to-run section matters as much as the installation table: an electric resistance heater turns each kWh into heat at 100%, but electricity often costs more per unit of energy than gas, and a heat pump delivers several units of heat for each unit of electricity. Use the calculator with your real prices before you decide.
Before the installer arrives
- Know whether you have a gas connection and usable ducts: it saves a lot.
- Check the age and capacity of your electrical panel if you are considering a heat pump or electric furnace. Our panel upgrade guide shows what that can cost.
- Have your home’s load calculated instead of copying the old size.
- Ask about the efficiency ratings of each system and what they mean for running cost.
Which one suits your case
If you already have gas and a lot of cold
Average installation and cheap to run. A furnace lasts 15 to 20 years with maintenance, according to PickHVAC. It needs a gas connection and a flue.
Cheap to install, expensive to run
It works for a very tight budget or a very small home. Electric baseboards cost $100 to $300 per unit plus $250 to $500 for installation, according to Inch Calculator (2023). An electric furnace can last 20 to 30 years.
Heating and air conditioning
The most expensive to install, but it also replaces the air conditioner, so the fair comparison is against gas plus air conditioning. With state or utility incentives the difference narrows.
The full comparison of a heat pump with a furnace plus air conditioner, with running cost by climate, is in our article on heat pump vs. air conditioner plus furnace. Here we focus on what it costs to install and how the 10-year bill compares.
What about cold climates?
Heat pumps once had a reputation for struggling in the cold, and models designed for low temperatures have improved a lot, but performance still depends on the model and on your winters. If you live in a place with long, severe cold, ask for the heating capacity at your design temperature, not only the rated figure, and ask what backup heat the installer would include. Our guide to heat pump costs and savings by climate goes deeper.
How to decide
- Check whether your home already has a gas connection and ductwork: it saves a lot on installation.
- Calculate your running cost with your actual electricity and gas prices in the calculator above.
- Ask for quotes on at least two systems and have each one separate equipment, labor and extras.
- Ask whether your electrical service can handle the new unit or needs an upgrade.
- Look for incentives from your state and your utility on DSIRE: the federal credit ended with 2025.
Is the cheapest system to install a bad choice?
Not always. If you rarely use heating, or you have a small space, the installation savings of an electric system can win. For regular use in a cold climate, the running cost usually dominates.
Do I need to change the flue or the gas line?
Possibly. PickHVAC lists gas line adjustments at $200 to $800 and flue changes at $300 to $1,500 when you replace a gas furnace.
Can I add cooling at the same time?
If you choose a heat pump, it provides both. Otherwise, see the air conditioner replacement calculator for the cooling side.
For the full comparison, read heat pump versus air conditioner plus furnace, and for the whole system price, what drives HVAC replacement costs.
In short
Installing a heating system is a decision about the next 15 to 20 years, so the running cost deserves more attention than the invoice. Use your own electricity and gas prices, check what your home already has (gas, ducts, panel capacity) and ask for quotes on at least two systems. The cheapest one on installation day is not always the cheapest one over the life of the equipment.
Worth reading alongside this one: Heat Pump vs. Air Conditioner Plus Furnace: Cost and Savings and Air-Source Heat Pump: Cost and Savings by Climate.
