A portable generator is much cheaper ($300 to $3,000 according to ConsumerAffairs), but you have to take it out, refuel it and start it by hand. A standby one costs between $10,000 and $25,000 for the whole house, starts by itself and runs longer. Use the calculator to compare the total cost over the years you will use it.
How much would each generator cost over the years?
Our own calculation with ConsumerAffairs ranges (portable: $300 to $3,000; standby: $10,000 to $25,000 total; standby maintenance: $200 to $500 a year; the portable’s, “minimal”). It does not include fuel, transfer switch or permits, because the sources give no figure. The starting values are examples, not a forecast.
Quick comparison
| Aspect | Portable generator | Standby generator |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | $300 to $3,000 (ConsumerAffairs) | $10,000 to $25,000 for the whole house (ConsumerAffairs) |
| Installation | None; a transfer switch is optional and may require a permit (Honda) | Professional, with permits and inspections; installation often costs almost as much as the equipment (Honda) |
| Fuel | Gasoline or diesel, with manual refueling | Propane or natural gas |
| Starting | Manual: you take it outside, refuel and start it | Automatic, often in about 30 seconds |
| Runtime | Less than 24 hours before refueling | Several days with propane; longer with natural gas as long as there is supply |
| Power | Lower: may not run everything at once (Honda) | 12 to 20 kW for the whole house (ConsumerAffairs) |
| Maintenance | Minimum | $200 to $500 a year (ConsumerAffairs) |
| Lifespan | 20 to 25 years | 15 to 25 years |
Sources: ConsumerAffairs (updated October 30, 2026; commercial site), Honda Power Equipment (manufacturer), HomeGuide (undated) and Generac (manufacturer).
What each type costs
The cost over the years
The ten-year view
Price tags make the portable look like the obvious winner, and often it is. But a standby generator is a system you keep for years, so it helps to add maintenance. Using ConsumerAffairs’ $200 to $500 a year, ten years of upkeep adds $2,000 to $5,000 to the standby’s $10,000 to $25,000, for about $12,000 to $30,000 before fuel. The portable’s cost is mainly the purchase, plus fuel and the effort of running it.
What you pay for with the extra money is time and effort: the standby starts by itself in about 30 seconds, runs without you, and can power much more of the house. If outages are rare and short, that convenience may not be worth its price. If they are frequent or long, it may be the only thing that makes the cost sensible.
Where each one can let you down
Portable
Needs you at home. In a storm you must carry it out, refuel it, and keep gasoline stored safely. Runtime is under 24 hours before refueling, and it may not run everything at the same time.
Standby
Depends on its fuel. Natural gas needs the supply to stay on; propane needs a tank with enough in it, and Honda warns that in winter storms the generator and heating can use it up.
When a portable makes sense
- Tight budget and infrequent outages.
- You only need to power the essentials (refrigerator, lights, chargers) or to use it away from home too, because it can be moved.
- You accept taking it out, refueling and starting it yourself.
When a standby one makes sense
- Long or frequent outages, or people who depend on electrical medical equipment.
- You want it to start on its own, even if you are not home, and to power a large part of the house.
- You have natural gas or room for a propane tank. Honda warns that in winter storms the generator and heating can use up the propane.
It is our own synthesis of the sources, not a personal recommendation.
Safety: carbon monoxide
The CPSC (U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission) states that a portable generator must always run outdoors, at least 20 feet from the house, with the exhaust pointed away, and never in a house, garage, basement, crawl space or shed: opening doors or windows is not enough. It recommends battery-powered carbon monoxide alarms on every floor and next to bedrooms. It estimates about 85 deaths a year from generator poisoning (average for 2017 to 2019). Source: CPSC (September 29, 2022).
Rules and neighbors
Generators are noisy, and both the placement and the noise can be regulated. Check your local ordinances and your homeowners association, if you have one, before you buy, and ask your installer about the required distance from windows, doors and property lines. For a portable unit the CPSC recommends at least 20 feet from the house. A standby unit has its own placement rules, which your installer and local inspector will apply.
A short pre-purchase checklist
- A written list of what you need to power and how long outages last in your area.
- Battery-powered carbon monoxide alarms on every floor and near bedrooms, in place before the first use.
- A safe connection plan: a transfer switch or interlock installed by a licensed electrician, never a plug into a wall outlet.
- Somewhere safe to store fuel, and a way to keep it fresh.
- Quotes in writing that name equipment, switch, installation, permit and warranty.
Deciding, step by step
- Add up the appliances you want to keep running and calculate the power (see our sizing calculator).
- Estimate how many outage days you usually have per year and how long they last.
- Use the calculator to compare the total cost of a portable and a standby one.
- Ask for installation quotes, with transfer switch and permits in writing.
- Install carbon monoxide alarms before using any generator.
Is there a middle option?
For some homeowners, a portable generator connected through a properly installed transfer switch gives more convenience than extension cords. Honda says the switch is optional for a portable and may require a permit. Ask an electrician what it would cost in your case.
Which one lasts longer?
The table shows 20 to 25 years for a portable and 15 to 25 for a standby. Maintenance matters more than the label.
Do I need to consider a battery instead?
It is a fair question, especially for short outages and essential loads. See generator versus home battery.
If you are still undecided after reading the comparison, the question that usually settles it is how you would feel during a three-day outage in the worst weather your area gets. If the answer is “fine, with a few essentials running”, a portable unit and a good plan are enough. If the answer involves medical equipment, a frozen pipe risk or a household that cannot be without heat, the extra cost of an automatic system starts to look like what it is: insurance you pay for in advance.
When you are ready to size the machine and price the job, use the generator size calculator and the whole-house generator cost calculator, and read the safety guide before anything is switched on.
