Spray Foam, Fiberglass or Cellulose: Insulation Compared

Fiberglass Cellulose Foam

Fiberglass is the cheapest option and DIY-friendly; cellulose performs slightly better per inch and fills attics well, but absorbs moisture; spray foam is the most expensive, the one that insulates most per inch and the only one that seals air, although it requires an installer. There is no insulation that is best at everything: it depends on the space, the moisture and the budget.

How much thickness do you need with each insulation?

Fit in your space–
Thinnest–
Cheapest (approximate)–

Our own calculation. The inches come from dividing the R-value you want by each source’s R per inch. The cost is HomeGuide’s installed price per sq ft multiplied by your area: it does not change with thickness, because the source does not break it out. The 14-inch value is only an example.

How much each one insulates per inch

R-value per inch (the higher the R, the better each inch insulates)R-0R-2R-4R-6R-8Fiberglass · HomeGuideR-2.2 to 2.9Fiberglass · Fine HomebuildingR-2 to 4.2Cellulose · HomeGuideR-3.1 to 3.8Cellulose · Fine HomebuildingR-3.2 to 3.8Open-cell foam · HomeGuideR-3.5 to 3.7Open-cell foam · Fine HomebuildingR-3.5 to 3.6Closed-cell foam · HomeGuideR-5 to 7Closed-cell foam · Fine HomebuildingR-6.5
HomeGuide (undated) and Fine Homebuilding (May 22, 2023). The two sources do not match, especially on fiberglass (Fine Homebuilding gives R-3.1 to 4.2 per inch for batts and R-2 to 4.2 blown, depending on density).

Sources: HomeGuide and Fine Homebuilding. Bob Vila gives up to R-7 for closed-cell foam and up to R-3.8 for fiberglass.

What each insulation costs

InsulationInstalled, per sq ftMaterial only
Fiberglass batts$0.80 to $2.60 (HomeGuide)$0.30 to $1.30 per sq ft (HomeGuide); $0.30 to $1.50 (Bob Vila)
Blown-in (fiberglass or cellulose)$1.00 to $2.80 (HomeGuide)Cellulose: $0.30 to $1.80 per sq ft (HomeGuide)
Open-cell foam$1.00 to $4.50 (HomeGuide)$0.30 to $0.50 per board foot (HomeGuide); $0.44 to $0.65 (Bob Vila)
Closed-cell foam$1.00 to $4.50 (HomeGuide)$0.90 to $1.00 per board foot (HomeGuide); $1.00 to $1.50 (Bob Vila)

Sources: HomeGuide (undated) and Bob Vila (March 1, 2023). A board foot is 1 foot × 1 foot × 1 inch: it is not comparable with the price per sq ft of surface. HomeGuide itself gives $1.50 to $5.00 per sq ft for foam in one section and $1.00 to $4.50 in another.

Air, moisture, fire and health

AspectFiberglassCelluloseFoam
Air barrierNoNo (although the dense type resists leaks better)Yes, open and closed
HumidityBatts are not suitable below grade; if they get wet, the fibers mat downAbsorbs water and releases it when drying; leaks can go unnoticed; above grade onlyOpen: lets vapor through; closed: blocks vapor
FireThe sources do not address itUsually treated with borax as a retardantExposed, it must be covered with something that provides the required fire resistance; closed-cell in too thick a layer can cause a fire
Installation and healthMask and long sleeves; DIY possibleMask; loose-fill blowing in attics is DIY, dense-pack is for professionalsLeave the house during application; odors that may last; certified technician
Lifespan (HomeGuide)80 to 100 years, check every 15 to 2020 to 30 years; starts to degrade after 15Up to 80 years; up to 30 on the underside of the roof deck

Sources: Fine Homebuilding (May 22, 2023), HomeGuide and Bob Vila. Fine Homebuilding clarifies that well-mixed and properly applied foam is inert once cured.

How to read the price per inch

A cheaper material that insulates less per inch may need more thickness to reach the same R-value, which is why the table in this guide gives both cost and R-value per inch. If your attic joists are deep, thickness is easy; if you are filling a 3.5-inch wall cavity, every inch counts and a higher R-value per inch (the main advantage of foam) can justify its price. The calculator above shows how much thickness each material needs for the R-value you choose, and that number, not the price per square foot alone, is what to compare.

Where each one belongs in the house

Attic floor

Blown-in fiberglass or cellulose is the common choice because it covers the joists and fills irregular spaces. Batts also work if they are fitted without gaps.

Walls

New construction can use batts. In closed walls, blown-in or dense-pack material is typical, and foam is sometimes used where air sealing is the goal.

Crawl spaces and basements

Moisture is the issue. The sources warn that batts are not suitable below grade and that cellulose absorbs water, so foam is often discussed for these areas.

Installation matters as much as the material

An R-value on a label assumes the product is installed correctly. In practice, gaps around pipes and wires, batts squeezed into spaces too small for them, and missing air sealing can erase much of the difference between a cheap material and an expensive one. That is why a well-installed fiberglass job can beat a poorly done foam one. When you compare quotes, ask what air sealing is included, how the installer verifies coverage, and how depth or thickness will be measured at the end of the job.

When to choose each

  • Fiberglass: tight budget, DIY and exposed cavities; it is the cheapest (HomeGuide, Fine Homebuilding, Bob Vila).
  • Blown cellulose: attics and irregular cavities, because it fills better than batts; always above grade and with care about moisture (HomeGuide, Fine Homebuilding).
  • Open-cell foam: when you want to seal air and the space is irregular; it lets vapor through (Fine Homebuilding, HomeGuide).
  • Closed-cell foam: when there is little space and a lot of moisture, such as basements and crawl spaces; it is the most expensive and requires a certified technician (HomeGuide, Fine Homebuilding).

From here to a decision

  • Find out the R-value you need in your zone (see the table in our attic article).
  • Measure the available space and check how much thickness each insulation needs with the calculator.
  • Decide whether you need to seal the air: foam does; fiberglass and cellulose need separate sealing.
  • Ask for at least three quotes with the final R-value, type and thickness in writing.
  • With foam, ask about the technician’s certification and how long you have to stay out of the house.

Safety while it is being installed

If you do any of this work yourself, wear a respirator or dust mask, gloves, long sleeves and eye protection, and ventilate the area. Fiberglass and cellulose dust irritate the skin, eyes and lungs. Spray foam is a job for professionals: fumes and mixing errors are real risks, and Fine Homebuilding notes that it is only inert once cured and well mixed.

Is spray foam worth the extra cost?

It can be, in places where air sealing and moisture control matter most, such as rim joists and crawl spaces. For a standard attic floor, cheaper options often deliver the R-value you need.

Is cellulose a fire hazard?

Cellulose is treated with fire retardants. As with any insulation, keep it away from heat sources like recessed lights not rated for contact, and follow the installer’s instructions.

Can I mix materials?

Yes, and some projects do, for example foam at the rim joists with fiberglass or cellulose elsewhere. Ask an installer what suits your house.

Once you pick a material, check how much you need in the R-value by climate zone guide and what it costs in the attic insulation calculator.

In conclusion

Fiberglass, cellulose and spray foam each have a place. Fiberglass is the cheapest and easiest to install, cellulose fills irregular spaces well, and foam insulates the most per inch and seals air, at a higher price. The material is only half the decision: where you install it and how well it is installed matter as much. Use the R-value you need, your budget and the space available to narrow the choice.

If this raised more questions, Attic Insulation Cost and Savings Calculator goes into more detail, and Energy Savings Calculator: Which Upgrade Pays Back Fastest? covers the next step.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top