Is Solar Worth It Without the Federal Tax Credit?

$

It depends mostly on how much you pay for electricity and on what your utility credits you for the power you send to the grid. Without the federal credit the system costs more and takes longer to pay for itself, but in many homes it still pays off. In others, it doesn’t.

30%Federal credit that no longer exists for people buying their system
up to $9,300What it would have been worth on an average 12 kW system
Dec. 31, 2025Credit deadline for new installations
3 waysTo pay: cash, a loan or a lease

The IRS states that the 30% residential clean energy credit does not apply to systems placed in service after December 31, 2025. On a 12 kW system costing about $31,000, that 30% would have been up to $9,300 (our own calculation on the average price from EnergySage). That is the incentive that has disappeared.

Average 12 kW system (average price $31,000) With 30% credit $21,700 Without credit $31,000 Difference: up to $9,300. Our own calculation (30% of $31,000), before other incentives.
Cost of an average system with and without the credit. Example figures based on EnergySage’s average price.

How the math changes without the credit

The simplest way to measure it is the payback period: the net cost of the system divided by what you save each year on your bill. Without the credit the cost goes up, and that is why the payback period gets longer.

The chart and table use the average $31,000 system and three levels of annual savings. They compare no incentive at all with a $5,000 state incentive, which is the example EnergySage uses. These are arithmetic examples, not forecasts for your home.

Years to pay back the investment ($31,000 system) $1,500 a year · no incentive20.7 years $1,500 a year · with $5,00017.3 years $2,400 a year · no incentive12.9 years $2,400 a year · with $5,00010.8 years $3,200 a year · no incentive9.7 years $3,200 a year · with $5,0008.1 years
Payback years = net cost ÷ annual savings. Our own calculation with example savings.
Annual savings on your billWith no incentiveWith a $5,000 state incentive
$1,50020.7 years17.3 years
$2,40012.9 years10.8 years
$3,2009.7 years8.1 years

The payback period is a simple calculation: it does not include loan interest, the loss of panel output over the years or future electricity price increases. EnergySage notes that rates rise about 3% a year, which, if it holds in your area, shortens the real payback period.

What really decides whether it pays off

Factor 1

What you pay for electricity

It is the most important factor. According to EnergySage, with rates of 15 cents per kWh or more solar usually delivers substantial savings, and below 10 cents the payback period gets much longer.

Look at your latest bill, divide the energy charge by the kWh used and compare it with those benchmarks.

Factor 2

How you are credited for surplus energy

If your utility pays you little for what you send to the grid, you are better off using the energy at home during sunny hours. Compensation rules (net metering) vary between states and even between utilities.

Ask in writing how it will be calculated in your case.

Factor 3

Incentives in your area

Some states and utilities offer tax credits, rebates, tax exemptions or renewable energy certificates. They vary a lot from place to place.

The database DSIRE lists the programs by state.

Factor 4

How long you will live in the house

If you plan to sell soon, you may not reach payback. EnergySage cites a SolarInsure study of California homes according to which solar can increase a home’s value by between 5% and 10%.

Check it with a local real estate agent.

Buy, finance or lease: they are not the same

The way you pay changes the result more than any other detail in the contract.

Paying cash

Purchase

It delivers the most long-term savings, because there is no interest or payments.

It is also the option that feels the loss of the credit most.

With a loan

Financing

You start saving from the first month, but interest eats into part of the savings.

Compare the total cost of the loan, not just the monthly payment.

Without buying

Lease or PPA

You don’t pay for the system, but the savings are usually smaller and contracts last 20 to 25 years, according to EnergySage.

Some states restrict these contracts.

In leases and PPAs the system owner is the company, and EnergySage explains that it may still claim the 48E business credit if construction begins before July 4, 2026 or it places the system in service before December 31, 2027. The company may pass part of that saving on to you, but it is not required to. Check the terms with your state’s public utilities commission and get everything in writing.

A decision rule for your own case

The table gives the shape of it: with $1,500 a year of savings on the $31,000 system, payback is 20.7 years with no incentive and 17.3 with a $5,000 state incentive, which is long. At $2,400 it is 12.9 or 10.8 years, and at $3,200 it is 9.7 or 8.1. A reasonable rule is to compare the payback with how long you expect to own the house and with the life of the panels, which warranties put at 25 years and often exceed. If payback is well under half that life, solar is probably a good bet; if it is near the limit, look at the other options in this article before you commit.

What you can do before spending on solar

If your payback looks long, it may be worth starting with upgrades that save money for less, such as air sealing, attic insulation and a smarter use of your thermostat. Our savings calculator ranks them. And check the other half of the equation: how your utility credits what you send to the grid, in net metering by state.

When it probably won’t pay off

Think twice if you match several of these points:

  • Your electricity bill is low or your rates are below 10 cents per kWh.
  • Your roof has a lot of shade or needs a major repair before installation.
  • You may sell the house within a few years.
  • Your utility pays very little for the energy you send to the grid and you use little during the day.

In that case it may be better to wait or to first improve insulation and appliances, which often deliver savings without such a large investment.

Before you sign, run this check

  • Gather your bills for the last 12 months and calculate your average cost per kWh.
  • Ask for at least three detailed quotes from licensed installers, with equipment, labor and permits listed separately.
  • Ask each installer for the estimated annual production and how they calculate it.
  • Check DSIRE for the incentives you qualify for and subtract them.
  • Divide the net cost by the estimated annual savings and compare it with how long you plan to live in the house.

If the resulting period is clearly shorter than that time, solar will probably pay off even without the credit. If it is very tight, compare first with a loan or a lease.

Do state incentives still exist?

Some do, and they vary by state and utility. DSIRE compiles them. Ask your installer which ones apply to your address.

Is a battery worth adding?

That is a separate decision. See whether a solar battery is worth it.

For estimates of price and payback in your state, see the cost calculator and the payback calculator.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top